Who this checklist is for

If you buy silicone sealants, rubber parts, or related polymer materials for a B2B operation and the purchase price isn't the only number that matters, this checklist is for you. I manage roughly $180,000 annually in silicone and elastomer spend across a 40-person manufacturing operation—six years of it, tracked in our procurement system. These are the seven steps our team runs before we approve any new supplier quote. The order matters. Skip step 1 and you'll pay for it in the total cost.

The whole run takes about two to three hours if you have drawings and usage data ready. If you've already got a vendor in place, I'd still recommend running steps 1, 2, and 5 at least once.

Step 1: Lock the spec by product code, not by category

The most common mistake I see is writing "silicone sealant" on a purchase request. That's a category, not a specification. We found that out the hard way—an internal audit flagged a request that just said "sealant," when the actual need was Dow Corning Silicone Sealant 789 grade (acetoxy cure, designed for glass and metal). Another team needed Dow Corning Silicone 791 grade in a different humidity environment—neutral cure, better for concrete and galvanized steel adhesion, and less corrosive. Same brand name. Different products. Completely different cost profile.

Calling it "Dow Corning 789" and "Dow Corning 791" is fine in conversation, but on the RFQ document you want the product code plus the cure type and adhesion class. If a supplier can't match the exact grade to a TDS, they shouldn't be on your bid list.

The check point most people skip: confirm three data points before you even write the request—hardness (Shore A or D), substrate bond, and cure speed. For O-rings, don't just reuse an old drawing. Run the dimensions through an o-ring gland calculator based on the actual pressure rating and operating temperature. We had an O-ring order where the old drawing from 2019 no longer matched the current gland dimensions. That one cost $900 in re-cut tooling. Now every seal goes through the calculator before it goes out to quote.

Step 2: Calculate the full cost, not the sticker price

Price data as of January 2025—exact figures will move, but the structure of this table doesn't.

Here's the worksheet we use for silicone sealants. The rubber-parts version is identical except for the line items in the middle:

We compared two suppliers in 2023. Supplier A quoted $18 per tube plus $240 freight. Supplier B quoted $22 per tube, all-in. We were ordering roughly 400 tubes—maybe 380, I'd have to check the system. On the surface, A looked $4 cheaper per unit. Actual TCO: A came to $7,930 after freight and our 4% scrap rate. B came to $8,800. A still won—but the gap was $870, not the $1,600 we'd initially assumed. A third supplier had a $340 "documentation fee" buried in the quote that only appeared after we asked "what's NOT included in this price?"

If you only remember one thing from this step: ask what's NOT included before you ask what the price is.

Step 3: Tie down the documentation requirements

Three documents are non-negotiable: TDS (technical data sheet), SDS (safety data sheet), and batch-level traceability. A supplier who can't produce batch traceability doesn't get a contract. We returned a full silicone sealant batch over this—the material looked fine on paper but cured with noticeably different flow rates on the line, and the supplier couldn't trace which production lot had shipped.

If you're buying for medical-adjacent or food-contact applications—think silicone and PP (polypropylene) components in breast pump assemblies or similar medical-grade housings—you also need biocompatibility documentation. That's an ISO 10993 class requirement and it's not something you can request after the goods arrive.

Step 4: Check shelf life at receiving, not at use

Silicone sealants have a real shelf life—typically 12–18 months. Put a receipt-date sticker on the case at receiving and reject anything with more than 25% of its shelf life already consumed. We had one shipment arrive with only five months left. The receiving clerk signed for it because the box was intact. We ended up scrapping nearly a third of the order because the cure accelerator had degraded in storage. Not ideal, but a lesson learned.

Step 5: Calculate scrap against your own process, not the vendor's promise

Every vendor presentation claims near-zero waste. Our own data across six years and roughly 4,200 line items shows the actual scrap rate for silicone sealant is 4.2% and for rubber components is 7.8%. That comes from partial tubes that cure before being fully used, cut-off waste, and the occasional bad lot.

Use your own process data. If you don't have any, use 5% as a placeholder. This check point is the one most teams skip.

Step 6: Insist on dual source for anything critical

If a single-source material sits on a line that cannot stop, you need a second vendor even if their price is higher. Our internal rule: 20% of the annual volume goes to a secondary supplier, and we re-qualify that supplier every 12 months. Yes, it costs more per unit. It also keeps your primary supplier from becoming complacent.

Step 7: Write the exit clause into the PO

Two clauses in our standard purchase order: a return clause for material defects above a 2% defect rate, and a 30-day cancellation clause if the supplier can't ship batch-matched material. When we first started inserting these, a couple of suppliers pushed back. In the past 18 months, I can't think of one who dropped off the vendor list over it. The ones who refuse these clauses don't get a second order.

Watch-outs: the things that trip most people up

Don't reuse a spec across incompatible substrates. Silicone sealant and PP will barely bond—that's why multi-material assemblies (like a breast pump's silicone valve and PP housing) need mechanical retention rather than adhesive. Silicone-to-silicone is fine. Silicone-to-PP is not, unless you've specified a primer.

Can you stack foam board insulation near your silicone stock? You can, but durability depends on how you stack it, not the material. If you're storing foam board insulation and silicone sealant in the same warehouse, keep them in separate bays—silicone off-gassing can migrate into the foam cells over time. Keep the foam stacked within its manufacturer's stated compression limit and away from solvent vapor.

Don't assume the brand name equals the product. Dow Corning's silicone line has dozens of formulations. Dow Corning Silicone Sealant 789 and Dow Corning Silicone 791 are not interchangeable. Always spec the Grade plus the cure type on the request.

Don't ignore freight on small orders. We analyzed our 2023 PO data and found that orders under $2,000 carried an average freight cost of 22% of unit price. Consolidate POs where you can, and source locally when the annual volume doesn't justify the shipping.

Celanese Materials Team

Application-focused polymer guidance for processors, OEM engineers, and sourcing teams.